Continuation of Modifications to Peer Review Practices

NOT-OD-26-069

NIH will continue temporary peer-review modifications through the October 2026 Advisory Council to address the backlog from the 2025 federal funding lapse.

Key Changes:

  • Fewer applications will be discussed: Only 30–35% (down from ~50%).
  • Applications in the middle third will be labeled “competitive but not discussed” and will still be considered for funding.
  • Applications in the lowest third will be labeled “not competitive and not discussed.”
  • Summary statements will be simplified:
    • No narrative discussion summaries
    • Include a brief consensus statement and bullet points of key scoring factors
    • Retain reviewer critiques for all applications
    • Include overall impact scores only for discussed applications 

These temporary changes are intended to improve review efficiency while maintaining fair evaluation during recovery from prior disruptions. 

News Filter